Analysis-Holism Scale

AHSAnalytic vs. Holistic Thinking Style
24 items 2007 α Total .68–.80 and subscales .52–.76 (Choi et al. 2007); subscales .76–.88 (Su, Monga & Jiang 2021) Free Choi, I., Koo, M., & Choi, J.A.

What it measures

The Analysis-Holism Scale measures individual differences in analytic versus holistic thinking — the cognitive styles Nisbett and colleagues associated with Western and East Asian cultures respectively, but which also vary between individuals within a culture. Its 24 items cover four facets of holistic thought: the belief that everything is causally interconnected (Causality), a preference for compromise and the middle ground over taking sides (Attitude Toward Contradictions), the expectation that things change in cyclical rather than linear, predictable ways (Perception of Change), and a tendency to attend to the whole field and context rather than isolated parts (Locus of Attention). Higher scores indicate more holistic thinking. In consumer research the subscales are often administered separately — for example, to test thinking style as a mechanism behind brand extension evaluations.

Response format

7-point Likert (1 = strongly disagree, 7 = strongly agree)

Scale items

Causality (6 items): belief that everything in the universe is causally interconnected. 7-point Likert; items averaged.

Attitude Toward Contradictions (6 items): preference for compromise and the middle ground over choosing between opposing positions. 7-point Likert; item 5 reverse-scored.

Perception of Change (6 items): expectation that change is cyclical and unpredictable (holistic) rather than linear and stable (analytic). 7-point Likert; items 1–4 and 6 reverse-scored.

Locus of Attention (6 items): tendency to attend to the whole field and context rather than to isolated parts. 7-point Likert; items averaged.

Full scale items shown. Always cite the original source when using this scale in research.

Usage notes & scoring

Scoring: each subscale is averaged, and a total score can be computed across all 24 items; higher scores indicate more holistic thinking. Reverse-score item 5 of Attitude Toward Contradictions and items 1–4 and 6 of Perception of Change (these express linear, stable change, the analytic view); item 5 of Perception of Change is the only positively keyed item in that subscale. Reliability (Choi et al. 2007): Study 1 (Korean students, n = 303) total α = .74, Causality .71, Attitude Toward Contradictions .69, Perception of Change .58, Locus of Attention .56; confirmatory sample (Korean students, n = 534) total α = .73, Causality .76, Contradictions .71, Change .71, Attention .67; Study 3 (104 Korean and 87 US students) total α = .68, Causality .76, Contradictions .52, Change .62, Attention .71, with total α = .72 for the Korean and .58 for the US students; Korean non-student adults (n = 319) total α = .80. Subscale reliabilities reported in consumer research by Su, Monga & Jiang (2021, Journal of Marketing Research 58(3), 579–594): Causality α = .88 (Study 4, n = 118) and α = .81 (Study 5, n = 348); Perception of Change α = .82 (Study 4) and α = .87 (Study 5); Locus of Attention α = .86 (Study 4) and α = .76 (Study 5). Su et al. did not administer the Attitude Toward Contradictions subscale, using a dialectical thinking measure instead. VALIDITY: Choi et al. (2007) reported convergent validity with attributional complexity, global thinking style and compromising conflict style, and discriminant validity from individualism–collectivism and self-construal (Study 2, n = 328). Known-groups validity: Koreans scored higher than Americans, and Korean students of Oriental medicine scored higher than other Korean students. Predictive validity: scores predicted categorisation and causal attribution judgements. Items were written in Korean and an English version was developed for US participants; check measurement equivalence before making cross-cultural comparisons. Item 24 loaded slightly more strongly on Perception of Change than on Locus of Attention but was kept in Locus of Attention on face-validity grounds. Individual subscales are also listed separately: Analytic/Holistic Thinking (Causality), Analytic/Holistic Thinking (Perception of Change subscale) and Analytic/Holistic Thinking (Locus of Attention); see also Dialectical Thinking.

Recommended companion scales

Citation

Choi, I., Koo, M., & Choi, J.A. (2007). Individual differences in analytic versus holistic thinking. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 33(5), 691–705.

Find on Google Scholar

Keywords

#analyticthinking#holisticthinking#cognitivestyle#AHS#cross-cultural#thinkingstyle#East-West#informationprocessing#contextsensitivity#causality#perceptionofchange#locusofattention#contradiction

More Consumer Decision Making scales

Browse all 237 Consumer Decision Making scales →
View & search this scale interactively →

Free access to 2582+ psychometric scales at PsychScales