Dialectical Thinking

DIALTDialectical Self (Contradiction Dimension)
4 items 2015 α 0.85 Free Spencer-Rodgers, J., et al.

What it measures

A four-item scale measuring an individual's chronic tendency to perceive and hold contradictory beliefs, positions, and perspectives simultaneously. Items assess awareness of contradictions in the world, the presence of unresolvable contradictions in one's environment, the tendency to find merit in opposing arguments, and the experience of holding contradictory beliefs. Drawn from the contradiction dimension of the Dialectical Self Scale, the subscale captures the cognitive openness to paradox and ambiguity that characterises East Asian dialectical thinking styles, though it has been applied cross-culturally in consumer research.

Response format

7-point Likert

Scale items

Full scale items shown. Always cite the original source when using this scale in research.

Usage notes & scoring

Alpha ranged from .75 to .85 across three studies — Su, Monga & Jiang (2021, Studies 4, 5, and 6; Journal of Marketing Research 58(3), 579–594). The lower estimates are .75 and .76; Study 4 reported .85. VALIDITY: Not discussed in the consumer application. Subset of the Dialectical Self Scale (Spencer-Rodgers et al. 2015), specifically the contradiction dimension. Originally developed to measure cultural differences in self-concept structure, particularly the greater acceptance of contradiction in East Asian vs. Western thinking. Cross-cultural applications should consider whether the scale functions equivalently across cultural groups.

Recommended companion scales

Citation

Spencer-Rodgers, Julie, et al. (2015). The dialectical self scale: Contradiction, change, and holism in the East Asian self-concept. Unpublished manuscript. [Applied by: Su, Lujun, Alokparna Basu Monga, and Yuwei Jiang (2021). How life-role transitions shape consumer responses to brand extensions. Journal of Marketing Research, 58(3), 579–594.]

Find on Google Scholar

Keywords

#dialecticalthinking#contradiction#holisticthinking#EastAsian#cognitivestyle#paradox#ambiguitytolerance#trait

More Consumer Behaviour scales

Browse all 650 Consumer Behaviour scales →
View & search this scale interactively →

Free access to 2582+ psychometric scales at PsychScales